Monday, February 6, 2023

Can you shoot down a Chinese balloon with a rifle from the ground?

The recent passage of a Chinese balloon at 60,000 ft (20km) altitude over US soil made headlines. One question many Americans are wondering is: would it be possible to shoot down the balloon with a rifle?

To answer this question, I made some assumptions, and then a simulation in Mathematica using available information on bullet trajectories.

For the bullet, I assumed an AR-15, a common rifle in the USA, was used with a muzzle velocity of 1000 m/s. I further assumed a 5.56 NATO round (I'm not a gun expert so I assume this fits together?) and that bullet has a mass of 4 grams, and drag coefficient of around 0.3 (see https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA530895.pdf). So then we can plug and chug:


mbullet = 4*10^-3; (* bullet mass in kg *)
dragCoefficient =0.3; 
airDensity = 1.29; (* kg/m^3 *)
bulletDiameter =5.70*10^-3 ;(* diameter in meters *)
g=9.81; (* graviational acceleration in m/s *)
sumF=-g*mbullet-(1/2)*dragCoefficient*airDensity*(\[Pi]*bulletDiameter^2 / 4 )* (y'[t]*Abs[y'[t]]); (* note: need to account for the sign of the deceleration *)
eq1=Simplify[{y''[t]==sumF/mbullet}]; (* Newton's law *)
eq2= {y[0]==0};(* Initial condition, bullet fired from the ground *)
eq3 = {y'[0]==1000};(* Initial condition, bullet at 1000 m/s *)
system =Join[{eq1, eq2, eq3}];
tmax = 40;
s=NDSolve[system,y,{t,0,tmax}];
Plot[y[t]/.s,{t,0,tmax},Frame->True, FrameLabel->{"Time [s]", "Height [m]"}]

  

The result:

So the bullet only gets to 2km altitude, not even close to the 20km altitude of the balloon! 


We can further plot the velocity of the bullet over the trajectory using:

Plot[y'[t] /. s, {t, 0, tmax}, Frame -> True, 

 FrameLabel -> {"Time [s]", "Velocity [m/s]"}]

This gives us:

 

Solving for the end of the trajectory gets us -88 m/s. Since energy scales with v^2, it has less than 1% of the initial energy. For reference, a paintball travels at approximately 90m/s. Still, you don't want to get one of those in the eye, so that's why you should not fire guns into the air to try to shoot down Chinese balloons.

No comments:

Post a Comment